John Dewey’s Impact on Education Reforms in Turkey and the Soviet Union
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14516/ete.2016.003.002.005Parole chiave:
John Dewey, Pragmatism, Democracy, Education, Turkey, Soviet UnionAbstract
This theoretical analysis focuses on John Dewey’s ideas and activities regarding education reform and societal democratization in Turkey and in the Soviet Union, with particular emphasis on the period between the two World Wars. The springboard for the research was the fact that Dewey’s pragmatic conception of education represents one of the most influential tendencies in the development of pedagogy and education reforms in many countries all over Europe, and indeed the world. This research seeks to determine the essential features, forms, extents and outcomes of the influence that John Dewey’s activities and ideas have had on the educational policies and reforms in both countries. The circumstances and content of Dewey’s visits to both Turkey and the Soviet Union are analysed, alongside his reports, i.e., his own impressions of the visits he made, and his recommendations for the respective education reforms and thoughts on their application and their achievements. In addition, the wide scope and diversity of influence of Dewey’s ideas are also examined through the various translated editions of his books and articles, taking into consideration numerous studies devoted to his works. These methods of theoretical analysis and historical research led to the conclusion that John Dewey’s pedagogical ideas and activities made a significant impact among his contemporaries, and greatly influenced the education reforms in Turkey and the Soviet Union, where there is still significant interest in his concepts and the application of his ideas today. However, although Dewey’s conception of education was extensively examined, acknowledged and used in the aforementioned countries, albeit with certain modifications and developments, it ultimately became either too rigid or vulgarised through many superficial interpretations and manipulations.
Riferimenti bibliografici
Basgoz, I., & Wilson, H.E. (1968). Educational problems in Turkey: 1920-1940 [Problemas de educación en Turquía]. Bloomington: Indiana University.
Baum, M. (1955). Pragmatism [Pragmatismo]. In Winn, R.B. (Ed.), American philosophy [Filosofía estadounidense] (pp. 162-172). New York: Philosophical library.
Bisbee, E. (1951). The New Turks: Pioneers of the Republic, 1920-1950 [Nuevos Turcos: Pioneros de la República, 1920-1950]. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Bowen, J. (1965). Soviet education: Anton Makarenko and the years of experiment [Educación soviética: Anton Makarenko y los años experimentales]. Madison: University of Wisconsin.
Brickman, W.W. (1949). John Dewey’s Foreign Reputation as an educator [Reputación en el extranjero de John Dewey como educador]. School and Society, 70, 257-265.
Brickman, W. W. (1964a). Soviet Attitudes toward John Dewey as an Educator [Actitud soviética hacia John Dewey como educador]. In Lawson, D.E., & Lean, A.E. (Eds.), John Dewey and the World View [John Dewey y opinión mudial] (pp. 64-149). Carbondale: Soutbern Illinois University Press.
Brickman, W.W. (1964b). John Dewey and Overseas Education: An Introduction. In Dewey, J. Impressions of Soviet Russia and the Revolutionary World: Mexico, China and Turkey [John Dewey y la educación de ultramar: Introducción. En Dewey, J. Impresiones de Rusia soviética y mundo revolucionario: México, China y Turquía] (pp. 1-31). New York: Teachers College Columbia University Press.
Dalton, T.C. (2002). Becoming John Dewey (Dilemmas of a philosopher or a naturalist) [Convirtiéndome en John Dewey (Dilemas de un filósofo o de un naturalista]. Bloomington: Indiana University press.
Dewey, J. (1908). Religion and our schools [La Religión y nuestras escuelas]. Hibbert Journal, 6, 796-809.
Dewey, J. (1916). Democracy and education [Democracia y educación]. New York: The Macmillan Company.
Dewey, J. (1929). Impressions of Soviet Russia and the Revolutionary World: Mexico-China-Turkey [Impresiones de la Rusia soviética y del mundo revolucionario: México, China y Turquía]. New York: New Republic.
Dewey, J., La Follette, S., & Stolberg, B. (1938) Not Guilty: Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Charges Made against Leon Trotsky in the Moscow Trials [Inocencia: Reporte de la Comisión Examinadora sobre los cargos presentados contra León Trotski en los juicios de Moscú]. New York: Harper and Bros.
Dewey, J. (1961). Philosophy of Education (Problems of Men) [Filosofía de la Educación (Problema de hombres]. New Jersey: Littlefield, Adams and co.
Dewey, J. (1983). Report and Recommendation upon Turkish Education [Informe y recomendaciones a la educación turca ]. In Boydston, J.A. (Ed.), The Middle Works: Essays on Politics and Society, 1923-1924[Ensayos sobre política y sociedad, 1923-1924], vol. 15 of The Collected Works of John Dewey, 1882-1953 [Obras completes de John Dewey, 1882-1953] (pp. 15274-15307). Carbondale: Southern Illinois Press.
Dewey, J.M. (1951). Biography of John Dewey [Biografía de John Dewey]. In Schilpp, P.A. (Ed.), The Philosophy of John Dewey [Filosofía de John Dewey] (pp. 3-45). Illinoius: Open court.
Dykhuizen, G. (1973). The life and mind of John Dewey [Vida y pensamiento de John Dewey]. London and Amsterdam: Feffer and sons inc.
Edwards, R. (1991). A.S. Makarenko’s general educational ideas and their applicability to a nontotalitarian society [Ideas educativas generales A.S. Makarenko y su aplicabilidad a una sociedad no totalitaria]. (Tesis inédita). Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago.
Gehring, T., Bowers, B.F., & Wright, R. (2005). Anton Makarenko: The John Dewey of the U.S.S.R. [Anton Makarenko: El John Dewey de la Unión Soviética]. The Journal of Correctional Education, 56(4), 327-345.
Kilpatrick, W. H. (1951). Deweys influence on education [Influencia de Dewey en la educación]. In Schilpp, P.A. (Ed.), The philosophy of John Dewey [La filosofía de John Dewey] (pp. 447-473). Illinoius: Open court.
King, E.J. (1975). Other Schools and Ours [Otras escuelas y las nuestras]. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Kocer, H.A. (1983). The training of primary school teachers [Entrenamiento para profesores de nivel primario]. Istambul: Milli Egitim Bakanligi Basievi.
Martin, J. (2002). The Education of John Dewey [Educación de John Dewey]. New York: Columbia University Press.
Mchitarjan, I. (2000). John Dewey and the Development of Education in Russia Before 1930. Report on a Forgotten Reception [John Dewey y el Desarrollo de la Educación en Rusia antes de 1930. Informe sobre la recepción olvidada]. In Oelkers, J., & Rhyn, H., (Eds.), Dewey and European Education [Dewey y educación europea] (pp. 109-131). Dodrecht, Boslon and London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Passow, H.S. (1982). John Deweys influence on education around the world [Influencia de John Dewey en la educación alrededor de mundo]. Teachers college record, 83(3), 401-418.
Poop, J.A. (1998). Naturalizing philosophy of education (John Dewey in postanalitic period) [Filosofía naturalista de educación]. Southern Illinois: University press.
Rasel, B. (1998). Istorija zapadne filozofije [Historia de la filosofía occidental]. Beograd: Narodna knjiga.
Thomas, R.M., Sands, L.B., & Brubaker, D.L. (1968). Strategies for curriculum Change: Cases from 13 Nations [Estrategias para cambios de curriculum: Casos de 13 Naciones]. Scranton: Penn, International Textbook.
Turan, T. (2000). John Dewey’s Report of 1924 and his recommendations on the Turkish educational system revisited [Informe de John Dewey de 1924 y sus recomendaciones al sistema educativo turco revisitado]. History of education, 29(6), 543-555.
Welchman, J. (1995). Deweys ethical thought [Opinión ética de Dewey]. Ithaca and London: Cornell University press.
Wilson, L. (1928). Education in the Republic of Turkey [Educación en República de Turquía]. School and Society, 28, 601-610.
Wolf-Gazo, E. (1996). John Dewey in Turkey: An Educational Mission [John Dewey en Turquía: Misión educativa]. Journal of American Studies of Turkey, 3, 15-42.
Yilmaz, A. (1994). The preparation of elementary teachers during the early years of the Turkish Republic [Preparación de profesores de primarias durante los años tempranos de República turca]. (Tesis inédita). Lehigh University, Bethlehem.
Zorić, V. (2011). Utjecaj Johna Deweyja na reforme obrazovanja u Japanu, Kini i Sovjetskom Savezu [Influencia de John Dewey en las reformas educativas en Japón, China y Unión soviética]. Život i skola, 26, 25-38.
Zorić, V. (2015a). Fundamentals of John Dewey’s concept of civic education [Fundamentos del concepto de educación civil de John Dewey]. History of Education & Childrens Literature, 10(1), 427-445.
Zorić, V. (2015b). Moral i religija u pragmatizmu Džona Djuija [Moral y religion en pragmatismo de John Dewey]. Inovacije u nastavi, 28(2), 54-66.
Карпачева, Н.В. (2009). Педагогическое значение социальной среды в теории Джона Дьюи [Significado pedagógico del entorno socialista en teoría de John Dewey]. (Tesis inédita). Курский государственный университет, Курск.
Коробова, А.Э. (2000). Педагогические идеи Джона Дьюи и их интерпретация в отечественной педагогической теории и практике 20-30-х годов [Ideas pedagógicas de John Dewey y sus interpretaciones en la práctica y teoría pedagógica local de los años 20 y 30]. (Tesis inédita). Волгоградская государственная академия физической культуры, Саратов.
Медынский, Е. Н. (1926). История педагогики в связи с экономическим развитием общества [Historia de la pedagogía en relación con el desarrollo económico de la sociedad], Vol. II. Москва: Работник просвещения.
Шацкий, С.Т. (1921). Предисловие [Prólogo]. In Дьюи Д. Демократия и образование: Введение в философию воспитания [Democracia y educación: valores y educación filosófica] (pp. 5-6). Москва: Редакия журнала «Работник просвещения» / ЦК Всерос. союза работников просвещения.
Шевкин, B.C. (1952). Педагогика Дьюи на службе современной американской реакции [Días de Pedagogía en servicio de reacción norteamericana]. Москва: Учпедгиз.
